You are here

Embedded Case Study Methods
Share

Embedded Case Study Methods
Integrating Quantitative and Qualitative Knowledge

  • Roland W. Scholz - Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, Zurich, Switzerland, University of Zurich, Switzerland
  • Olaf Tietje - Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, Zurich, Switzerland

October 2001 | 408 pages | SAGE Publications, Inc
Bridging the gap between quantitative and qualitative approaches, Embedded Case Study Methods presents methods for interrelating and integrating the variables, findings, and evaluations from the facets of the case (i.e., different perspectives of inquiry such as participant observation, open-ended interviews, etc.) or sub-units of case inquiry. Using case examples from five different disciplines (neuropsychology, education, law, business, and environmental sciences), the authors show the reader how to use the embedded case design to enhance synthesis and knowledge integration. The authors share their broad knowledge of the philosophy of science to explain the rationale behind each step of embedded case designs, and recap each explanation with concept recaps called "lessons to be learned." In addition, they include a variety of boxes that offer statistical models for doing the analysis. This book offers readers a sophisticated approach to integrating mixed methods in case studies.

 
1. Introduction
Methods of Knowledge Integration  
Embedded Case Studies for Complex, Contextualized Problems  
Historical Landmarks  
 
PART I: CASE STUDY DESIGN AND SYNTHESIS
 
2. Types of Case Studies
Design  
Motivation  
Epistemological Status  
Purpose  
Format  
Data Collection and Methods of Knowledge Integration  
 
3. The Use of Case Studies in Different Disciplines
Neuropsychology  
Educational Sciences  
Law  
Business  
Environmental Sciences  
 
4. The Architecture of Knowledge Integration in Embedded Case Studies
The Architecture of Embedded Case Studies  
Strategies of Synthesis  
The Brunswikian Lens Model  
Types of Knowledge Integration  
 
5. The ETH-UNS Case Study Zurich North
The Zurich North Case  
Case Prospects and History  
Understanding the Case  
Faceting the Case for Embedded Case Design  
Constraints of the Study  
Organizing the Study  
 
PART II: METHODS OF KNOWLEDGE INTEGRATION
 
6. Overview
 
7. The Methods in Brief
 
8. How to Choose the Right Method
 
PART III: THE METHODS IN DETAIL
 
9. Formative Scenario Analysis
The Rationale  
The Method in Detail  
 
10. System Dynamics
The Rationale  
The Method in Detail  
 
11. Multi-Attribute Utility Theory
The Rationale  
The Method in Detail  
 
12. Integrated Risk Management
The Rationale  
Incorporating Different Perspectives  
The Method in Detail  
 
13. Mediation: Area Development Negotiations
The Rationale  
The Method in Detail  
 
14. Future Workshops
The Rationale  
The Method in Detail  
 
15. Experiential Case Encounter
The Rationale  
The Method in Detail  
 
16. Synthesis Moderation and Group Techniques
The Rationale  
The Method in Detail  
 
17. Material Flux Analysis
The Rationale  
The Method in Detail  
 
18. Life Cycle Assessment
The Rationale  
The Method in Detail  
 
19. Bio-Ecological Potential Analysis
The Rationale  
The Method in Detail  
 
PART IV: VALIDATION PERSPECTIVES
 
20. The Validation of Embedded Case Studies
The Rationale  
Validation of Embedded Case Studies: A Practical View  
 
References
 
Index
 
About the Authors

"If you were part of a study team trying to figure out what to do in a complicated (i.e., multi-party, multi-issue, technically complex) situation, you would want to rush out and get a copy of Embedded Case Study Methods by Roland Scholz and Olaf Tietje. Using their own Zurich North case study to explain the proper use of case study methods, they demonstrate how eleven different techniques -- including integrated risk assessment, multi-attribute utility theory, scenario analysis, future workshops, and a kind of mediation called Area Development Negotiation -- ought to be used to develop collaborative solutions. Along the way, they destroy conventional distinctions between quantitative and qualitative methods and offer (finally!) an integrated approach that applies equally well to problem framing, option generation, and the management of stakeholder encounters. Most of the relevant literature (from more than a dozen disciplines) is reviewed in detail. What more could a study team member want?"

LAWRENCE SUSSKIND
Ford Professor of Urban and Environmental Planning at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and co-author of the award-winning Consensus Building Handbook (Sage, 1999)

"Scholz and Olaf have developed an important methodology to integrate complex cases. Their approach combines the best of quantitative and qualitative methodologies to create new insights that would not be available to researchers using more conventional approaches."  

MAX H. BAZERMAN
Jesse Isador Straus Professor of Business Administration, Harvard Business School

"This is an excellent book that serves an important purpose. It should become a valuable resource in research methods courses covering issues of case research. Doctoral students especially, should find the book particularly helpful. The conceptual material and methods of knowledge integration presented in this book provide scholars with the background and tools necessary to conduct case studies that meet the field's most rigorous scientific standards."

Organizational Research Methods

This book should be required reading for anyone involved with case study analysis.

CANADIAN JOURNAL OF URBAN RESEARCH

This is a bold contribution to case study methodology, perhaps more suitable for postgraduate student considering a mixed methods approach, or a research team collaborating on a new type of project. Scholz and team introduce the transdisciplinary case study approach (TCS), which they developed at the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology (ETH). There are case studies from 5 different disciplines: neuropsychology, education, law, business, and environmental sciences. An excellent guide for any researcher contemplating a trans-disciplinary or complex case study.

Mrs Udeni Salmon
Salford Business School, Salford University
November 28, 2014

The book is at the forefront of assessing good case study approaches, how they can be managed, and the conditions under which they are effective. The book makes academics aware of useful theories to explore ways in which case studies can be useful.

Mrs CARMEN JACA
Industrial Management, University of Navarra
May 30, 2014

Embedded case study methods: Integrating quantitative and qualitative knowledge focuses on different aspects of the case study research approach, and argues that systematic embedded case studies can be used as a research methodology in its own right. The authors show how embedded case studies can be employed to qualitative, quantitative and mixed research approaches. The text provides examples of how embedded case studies can be used in different fields to solve complex research problems in areas such as: neuropsychology, educational sciences, law, business and environmental science. The book consists of 20 chapters which are divided into four parts. Part one covers case study design and synthesis which introduces the reader to different types of case studies and their design, as well as the purpose and methods of knowledge integration. Part two discusses methods of knowledge integration in relation to the different methods which can be applied to different types of embedded case studies in areas such as: integrated risk management, life cycle assessment, mediation – area development, bio-ecological potential analysis, methods for medical cases, and more cases are listed in the book, as well as how to choose the right method for different areas of research. Part three contains the largest amount of chapters within the book and its main focus is about discussing in detail the methods which were briefly present to the reader previously in part two of the text. Part four covers validation perspectives in terms of setting out the rationale for research projects and providing validation of embedded case studies. The text includes useful tables and illustrations throughout the book to aid the read and is assessable for both undergraduate and postgraduate students planning to employ embedded case study research.

Mr Gary McKenna
School of Computing, University of the West of Scotland
January 30, 2013

This is a wonderfully in-depth reference for case study research. It does a fine job of presenting the analytic nature of case study research, which is suitable for doctoral level study.

Dr Marilyn Kirshbaum
Nursing and Health Studies, Huddersfield University
July 6, 2010

Preview this book

For instructors

Select a Purchasing Option


Paperback
ISBN: 9780761919469
$102.00

Hardcover
ISBN: 9780761919452
$164.00

This title is also available on SAGE Research Methods, the ultimate digital methods library. If your library doesn’t have access, ask your librarian to start a trial.