You are here

Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin

Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin

eISSN: 15527433 | ISSN: 01461672 | Current volume: 47 | Current issue: 3 Frequency: Monthly

Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin offers an international forum for the rapid dissemination of original empirical papers in all areas of personality and social psychology. The journal is published monthly - so you'll receive over 120 of the best articles each and every year.

Debate and Controversy
Each issue of Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin brings you challenging articles that stimulate dialogue and reflect the many schools of thought now active in the field. At the forefront of new developments, Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin reports research as it occurs. In fact, PSPB's innovative articles often provide the first accounts of research breakthroughs.

Contemporary Topics
In Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, you'll find articles by distinguished scholars on a variety of contemporary topics. Examples include attitudes and attitude changes, close relationships, gender and age stereotypes, group processes, intergroup relations, interpersonal attraction, morality, political action, prejudice, self-concept, social influence, and values.

Visit SPSP's journal homepage for additional information.

This journal is a member of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE)

The Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin is an official journal for the Society of Personality and Social Psychology. The journal is an international outlet for original empirical papers in all areas of personality and social psychology.

Michael D. Robinson North Dakota State University, USA
Yuen J. Huo University of California, Los Angeles, USA
Emily A. Impett University of Toronto Mississauga, Canada
Benjamin M. Wilkowski University of Wyoming, USA
Managing Editor
Supriya Bidola SAGE Publishing, USA
Associate Editors
Joshua M. Ackerman University of Michigan, USA
Modupe Akinola Columbia University, USA
Marco Brambilla University of Milano Bicocca, Italy
Lucian Gideon Conway III University of Montana, USA
Maureen A. Craig New York University, USA
Christian S. Crandall University of Kansas, USA
Jaap J. A. Denissen Utrecht University, Netherlands
Leonel Garcia-Marques Universidade de Lisboa, Portugal
Keiko Ishii Nagoya University, Japan
Michael W. Kraus Yale University, USA
Edward P. Lemay Jr. University of Maryland, USA
Andrea L. Meltzer Florida State University, USA
Corinne A. Moss-Racusin Skidmore College, USA
John V. Petrocelli Wake Forest University, USA
Aneeta Rattan London Business School, United Kingdom
Jessica D. Remedios Tufts University, USA
Luis M. Rivera Rutgers University-Newark, USA
Joanna Schug College of William & Mary, USA
Luke D. Smillie University of Melbourne, Australia
Kate Sweeny University of California, Riverside, USA
Andrew R. Todd University of California, Davis, USA
Eddie M. W. Tong National University of Singapore, Singapore
Sarah S. M. Townsend University of Southern California, USA
Michelle R. vanDellen University of Georgia, USA
Gregory D. Webster University of Florida, USA
Consulting Editors
Guido Alessandri Sapienza University of Rome, Italy
Angela Bahns Wellesley College, USA
Levi R. Baker University of North Carolina at Greensboro, USA
Fiona Kate Barlow The University of Queensland, Australia
Peter Belmi University of Virginia, USA
Monica Biernat University of Kansas, USA
Kevin R. Binning University of Pittsburgh, USA
Kevin L. Blankenship Iowa State University, USA
Wiebke Bleidorn Wiebke Bleidorn, University of California, Davis, USA
Courtney Bonam University of California, Santa Cruz, USA
Mark J. Brandt Michigan State University, USA
Tiffany N. Brannon University of California, Los Angeles, USA
Nyla R. Branscombe University of Kansas, USA
Amy B. Brunell The Ohio State University, Mansfield, USA
C. Daryl Cameron The Pennsylvania State University, USA
Trevor I. Case Macquarie University, Australia
Lei Chang University of Macau, China
Margaret S. Clark Yale University, USA
Taya R. Cohen Carnegie Mellon University, USA
Angelo B. Costa Pontificia Universidade Catolica do Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil
Jarret Crawford The College of New Jersey, USA
Jennifer Crocker Ohio State University, USA
Jan De Houwer Ghent University, Belgium
Thomas F. Denson University of New South Wales, Australia
M. Brent Donnellan Michigan State University, USA
John F. Dovidio Yale University, USA
Daniel A. Effron London Business School, UK
Anthony M. Evans University of Tilburg, Netherlands
Tal Eyal Ben Gurion University of the Negev, Israel
Russell H. Fazio Ohio State University, USA
Frank D. Fincham Florida State University, USA
Ronald S. Friedman University at Albany, USA
David C. Funder University of California, Riverside, USA
Randi L. Garcia Smith College, USA
Bertram Gawronski The University of Texas at Austin, USA
Yuthika U. Girme Simon Fraser University, Canada
Peter Glick Lawrence University, USA
Mario Gollwitzer Philipps-Universität Marburg, Germany
Amie Gordon University of Michigan, USA
Katharine H. Greenaway University of Melbourne, Australia
Nick Haslam University of Melbourne, Victoria, Australia
Steven J. Heine University of British Columbia, Canada
Erin P. Hennes Purdue University, USA
P.J. Henry New York University Abu Dhabi, USA
Joshua A. Hicks Texas A&M University, USA
Verlin B. Hinsz North Dakota State University, USA
Arnold K. Ho University of Michigan, USA
Sara D. Hodges University of Oregon, USA
Joshua J. Jackson Washington University in St. Louis, USA
Jeremy P. Jamieson University of Rochester, USA
Samantha Joel Western University, Canada
Camille S. Johnson San Jose State University, USA
Peter K. Jonason University of Padua, Italy
Kimberly Kahn Portland State University, USA
Mary E. Kite Ball State University, USA
Joachim Krueger Brown University, USA
Nour Kteily Northwestern University, USA
Robert D. Latzman Georgia State University, USA
Sean M. Laurent University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, USA
Kristin Laurin University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada
Richard E. Lucas Michigan State University, Department of Psychology, USA
Laura V. Machia Syracuse University, USA
C. Neil Macrae University of Aberdeen, Scotland, UK
Keith B. Maddox Tufts University, USA
E. J. Masicampo Wake Forest University, USA
Khairul A. Mastor Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, Malaysia
Allen R. McConnell Miami University, USA
Brian P. Meier Gettysburg College, USA
Yuri Miyamoto Hitotsubashi University, Japan
Nora A. Murphy Loyola Marymount University, USA
Rebecca Neel University of Toronto, Canada
Michele Nuijten Tilburg University, Netherlands
Nickola C. Overall University of Auckland, New Zealand
Daphna Oyserman University of Southern California, USA
Efrén O. Pérez University of California, Los Angeles, USA
Sylvia Perry Northwestern University, USA
Richard E. Petty Ohio State University, USA
Evava S. Pietri Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis, USA
Jason E. Plaks University of Toronto, Canada
E. Ashby Plant Florida State University, USA
Nairán Ramírez-Esparza University of Connecticut, USA
Kyle Ratner University of California, Santa Barbara, USA
Harry T. Reis University of Rochester, USA
Jennifer A. Richeson Yale University, USA
Francesca Righetti Free University Amsterdam, The Netherlands
Jane L. Risen University of Chicago, USA
Steven O. Roberts Stanford University, USA
Clay Routledge North Dakota State University, USA
Tamar Saguy IDC, Israel
John Sakaluk Western University, Canada
Diana T. Sanchez Rutgers University-New Brunswick, USA
Krishna Savani Nanyang Technological University, Singapore
Rebecca J. Schlegel Texas A&M University, USA
Toni Schmader University of British Columbia, Canada
Abigail A. Scholer University of Waterloo, Canada
Norbert Schwarz University of Southern California, USA
J. Nicole Shelton Princeton University, USA
Nurit Shnabel Tel-Aviv University, Israel
Paul Silvia University of North Carolina at Greensboro, USA
Linda J. Skitka The University of Illinois at Chicago, USA
Richard B. Slatcher University of Georgia, USA
Michael Slepian Columbia University, USA
Erica B. Slotter Villanova University, USA
Olga Stavrova Tilburg University, Netherlands
Chadly Stern University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign, USA
Jerry Suls Feinstein Institute for Medical Research, USA
William von Hippel University of Queensland, Australia
Paul H. White University of Utah, USA
Robert E. Wickham Palo Alto University, USA
Clara L. Wilkins Washington University in St. Louis, USA
James H. Wirth The Ohio State University at Newark, USA
Kumar Yogeeswaran University of Canterbury, New Zealand
Michael Zarate University of Texas at El Paso, USA
Cristina Zogmaister University of Milan-Bicocca, Italy
  • Applied Social Sciences Index & Abstracts (ASSIA)
  • Biological Sciences Abstracts
  • Clarivate Analytics: Current Contents - Physical, Chemical & Earth Sciences
  • Corporate ResourceNET - Ebsco
  • Current Citations Express
  • EBSCO: Vocational & Career Collection
  • Family & Society Studies Worldwide (NISC)
  • Gale: Diversity Studies Collection
  • Health & Safety Sciences Abstracts
  • ISI Basic Social Sciences Index
  • Index Medicus
  • International Bibliography of Periodical Literature on the Humanities and Social Sciences (IBZ)
  • MasterFILE - Ebsco
  • NISC
  • OmniFile: Full Text Mega Edition (H.W. Wilson)
  • ProQuest: Applied Social Science Index & Abstracts (ASSIA)
  • ProQuest: CSA Sociological Abstracts
  • PsycINFO
  • PsycLIT
  • Psychological Abstracts
  • Risk Abstracts
  • SafetyLit
  • Scopus
  • Social SciSearch
  • Social Science Source
  • Social Sciences Citation Index (Web of Science)
  • Standard Periodical Directory (SPD)
  • TOPICsearch - Ebsco
  • Wilson Social Sciences Index Retrospective
  • The Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin (PSPB) is an official publication of the Society of Personality and Social Psychology (SPSP), Inc. PSPB is an international outlet for the rapid dissemination of original contributions based on empirical data in all areas of personality and social psychology. Occasionally, PSPB publishes other pieces of particular interest to members of SPSP, such as special topic issues, selected symposia, and invited addresses.

    All papers submitted to PSPB are reviewed with respect to their scholarly merit and the extent to which they advance valid knowledge about social behavior. To this end, submissions that include meta-analyses, replications, alternatives to null hypothesis significance testing, and single as well as multiple studies, are all considered.

    SPSP recommends that authors read “Improving the Dependability of Research in Personality and Social Psychology” and APA’s Ethical Principles of Psychologists and Code of Conduct Standard 8 before submitting manuscripts to PSPB.

    TOP Level II Guidelines

    As of January 1, 2021 PSPB has adopted TOP Level II guidelines. Some important changes to existing PSPB guidelines include:

    • Authors must post the following in a trusted repository (see trusted repositories) and link to them in the manuscript.
      • Materials
      • Analysis code
      • Any data that is not already publicly accessible
      • A codebook for interpreting the data file(s) describing all variables and how they are coded
    • Authors need to state whether study and analysis plan pre-registration exists or not.

    Exceptions should be communicated to the Editor directly in the cover letter and acknowledged in the Author Note on the title page. If you think you might need to request an exception, please check this FAQ guide first for help navigating common challenges to data and code sharing.

    Manuscript Preparation

    Compliance with these policies is verified upon submission of manuscripts. Failure to comply with the policies will prevent submission and review of manuscripts.

    Style: All manuscripts should follow the style guidelines set forth in the Publication Manual of the American Psychological Association, Seventh Edition (APA, 2020).

    Citations: Please take care to give credit where credit is due. In addition to citing papers, please cite and list in the reference section all data sets, programs, analytic tools and apps, and code/packages (with version numbers) that are not original to the current manuscript. Whenever possible, include a persistent identifier, such as a Digital Object Identifier (DOI). For example, an author using the R package lsr would run the code [citation("lsr")] to find the appropriate citation information, cite the package in the manuscript text [e.g., “We used R package lsr (Version 0.5; Navarro, 2015)”], and include it in their reference section:

    Navarro, D. J. (2015). Learning statistics with R: A tutorial for psychology students and other beginners (Version 0.5). Adelaide, Australia: University of Adelaide.

    Length: Manuscripts must not exceed 10,000 words in length, including the abstract, references, and notes. The word count must appear on the title page. Rare exceptions to this policy can be requested as part of the submission process (justified by the nature, number, or complexity of studies or methods reported, for example). Even in such cases, authors should strive to come as close as possible to 10,000 words.

    Abstract and keywords: The page following the title page must include an abstract of no more than 150 words, and below the abstract, 4-5 keywords.

    Methods reporting and sharing: all manuscripts must include a report of the following items for each study:

    • Explain how sample size was determined, including whether and how looking at the results influenced the collection of additional data. If sample size was determined ahead of time using a power analysis, please report the basis for the expected effect size and all information required to reproduce the power analysis.
    • Report (1) the total number of excluded observations, (2) the reasons for making these exclusions, (3) how they were distributed across conditions.
    • Disclose the existence of all variables and conditions that were part of the study. These can be summarized, or put in a footnote or supplementary material in the case of large numbers of variables, but there should be enough information for a reader to judge whether the variables and/or conditions are potentially theoretically relevant or not.
    • State the above two disclosures in the text of the manuscript (e.g., “We report all manipulations, measures, and exclusions in these studies”).
    • Report procedures in sufficient detail to allow close replication by an independent lab.
    • All manuscripts should report complete statistics relevant to the analyses, using supplementary materials if needed:
      • Cell means, SD, and n for experimental designs
      • Correlations between variables for multivariate designs including regression and repeated-measures
      • Inferential statistics with exact p-values (to 3 decimal places), effect sizes, and confidence intervals for effect sizes regardless of significance level
      • If figures use error bars, these should be explained in a caption (e.g., standard error, 95% confidence interval, etc.)
      • If meeting any of these requirements proves impractical, authors should explain why

    Authors are required to post to a trusted public online repository all stimulus materials that are not already publicly accessible, including the verbatim wording of all independent and dependent variable instructions, manipulations, and measures. A link to the materials should appear in the text of the manuscript. Exceptions must be identified at article submission. (If the research was conducted in a language other than English, the materials file can provide the original materials and a rough translation into English that has been created using Google Translate or a similar free online program, as long as the manuscript itself provides sufficient detail for reviewers and readers to evaluate the presented research.)

    Data sharing: Data (including all columns of data described anywhere in the manuscript) must be posted to trusted repository (see trusted repositories) and a link should appear in the manuscript. Exceptions must be identified at article submission. If you are using existing datasets that are already publicly accessible, please provide a link with appropriate citation (no need to upload separately). Data should ideally be in csv or a non-proprietary format. Ensure uploaded data are anonymous (e.g., make sure to remove potentially identifying information such as IP address, birthday, email address, name, latitude and longitude). Authors should also be cautious when posting rich datasets from identifiable subgroups and ensure that individuals cannot be identified based on “triangulating” across demographic variables such as age, gender, ethnicity, occupation, school, etc.


    Codebook: Authors should provide a guide to interpreting the data file (sometimes called a data dictionary or codebook). The codebook should define (a) what every variable name in the data file means (how it connects to the variables in the materials file) and (b) how each variable is coded (e.g., 0 = failed attention check, 1 = passed attention check). Even if authors cannot share all columns of data described in the manuscript, describe them all in the codebook. Here are some examples of codebooks that accomplish these criteria, as illustrations: Project Implicit, Joel (2018).

    Code sharing: Analysis code must be posted to a trusted repository and a link should appear in the manuscript. Exceptions must be identified at article submission. Authors must provide (commented/annotated) program code or syntax that demonstrates how data were analyzed or otherwise provide sufficient details to exactly reproduce all results in the manuscript.

    Result reporting: Data-based submissions must:

    • Report effect sizes and their confidence intervals for primary findings in each study.
    • Address issues of sample size and consequent issues of power in each study or, in the case of multiple-study articles, in the context of evaluating the overall case for the reliability of the primary findings. Please do not report “observed” power for a test calculated using the effect size estimate from that same test.

    Statistical power: Please report at least one power analysis for each study (see calculating and reporting power for guidance on selecting an appropriate power analysis and examples of how to write them up). Describe all information necessary for an independent researcher to reproduce the results of your power analysis, including the program you used, the specific test for which you were calculating power (e.g., was it one of the main effects, an interaction, or a follow-up pairwise comparison?), and all input values (e.g., effect size estimate, alpha, one-or-two-sided test, desired power, mean or median correlation among repeated measures).

    Preregistration: Please indicate within the manuscript whether each of the following elements for each study was preregistered and (if yes) provide a link to the time-stamped preregistration:

    • Study design (e.g. number of conditions, how key variables will be measured)
    • Planned sample size or a pre-planned stopping rule
    • Inclusion/exclusion criteria
    • Planned analyses

    Feel free to adapt the sample statements available here. If the answers to all questions are the same for all studies in the manuscript, you can include one overall statement for all studies. Any pre-registration form/template can be used, as long as they are publicly viewable in an independent registry that provides time-stamps and persistent links (options include:,, and

    For preregistered planned analyses: Please include a statement in the main body of the manuscript confirming that you have (a) reported all pre-registered analyses in the main body of the manuscript, appendices, and/or supplemental materials and (b) clearly marked any deviations from the preregistered analysis plan in the main body of the paper.

    Deviations from preregistration: Note any deviations from pre-registration in the main text of the manuscript and include reasons for the deviations. There are many reasons why deviations may occur (e.g., data extremely violating assumptions of pre-registered tests, unforeseen needed exclusions criteria) and deviations are not inherently problematic; they simply need to be clearly reported so that reviewers and readers have access to the information. If any pre-registered planned analyses are not included in the main manuscript, authors should make clear where those analyses do appear (e.g. in a specific appendix or supplement) or provide a rationale for not reporting the analyses at all.

    Exploratory analyses: Unplanned analyses that are done in addition to pre-registered planned analysis do not need to be labelled as deviations, since they are supplementing the pre-registered analyses rather than replacing them. However, these analyses should be clearly marked as not being part of the pre-registered analyses.

    Replication: PSPB will now consider manuscripts that directly (or closely) replicate the procedures of studies previously published at PSPB. Following other journals (e.g., Psychological Science and Journal of Research in Personality), the authors of a replication study must clearly articulate their rationale for conducting the replication and the interest value of it. Authors should inform the Editor that they are planning this replication-related work and this email should articulate the potential value of the contribution. Subsequently, the research will be evaluated in a two-stage sequence, the first of which involves an evaluation of the proposal (introduction plus methods and analysis plan) and the second of which involves an evaluation of the final product.

    Double-blind review: PSPB conforms to a double-blind peer review process. Please ensure that supporting files are anonymized as much as possible. If using the OSF, authors can create a view-only link that will remove their names from the project by checking the “anonymize” option (see If using AsPredicted, authors can create an anonymous PDF and include this URL in the paper for review purposes. In the manuscript itself, please remove self-citations when they can be used to identify any of the authors. Authors may substitute "Citation Blinded' in place of these identifying citations.

    Ethical Practices verification: Corresponding authors of submitted papers must verify that:

    • the same or substantially similar manuscript has not been simultaneously submitted for consideration by another journal
    • the same or substantially similar manuscript has not already been published in whole or part
    • data collection complied with current APA Ethical Principles of Psychologists and Code of Conduct
    • the raw data and related coding information underlying all findings of empirically-based publications will be shared consistent with SPSP’s (2020) Data Sharing Policy

    Manuscript Submission

    SAGE Track Submission: All manuscripts must be submitted through SAGE Track. Authors will receive login and password information to access the system and upload manuscripts. If you need submission assistance, contact the Managing Editor at SAGE Publications.

    If you or your funder wish your article to be freely available online to nonsubscribers immediately upon publication (gold open access), you can opt for it to be included in SAGE Choice, subject to payment of a publication fee. The manuscript submission and peer review procedure is unchanged. On acceptance of your article, you will be asked to let SAGE know directly if you are choosing SAGE Choice. To check journal eligibility and the publication fee, please visit SAGE Choice. For more information on open access options and compliance at SAGE, including self author archiving deposits (green open access) visit SAGE Publishing Policies on our Journal Author Gateway. Any inquiries regarding manuscript submission may be directed to the Managing Editor’s office:

    Supriya Bidola
    Managing Editor, PSPB
    SAGE Publications


    Individual Subscription, Print Only

    Institutional Subscription, E-access

    Institutional Subscription, Print Only

    Institutional Subscription & Backfile Lease, E-access Plus Backfile (All Online Content)

    Institutional Subscription, Combined (Print & E-access)

    Institutional Subscription & Backfile Lease, Combined Plus Backfile (Current Volume Print & All Online Content)

    Institutional Backfile Purchase, E-access (Content through 1998)

    Individual, Single Print Issue

    Institutional, Single Print Issue