Information for editors

Journal editorial board members

Welcome to the Editorial Board Members (EBMs) Hub. Whether you are an Early Career Researcher interested in taking the first steps to collaborate with a Journal, or an experienced researcher interested in joining an Editorial Board, you’re in the right place. Here you’ll find guidance on how to gain the experience needed to join an Editorial Board, how to make the most of Editorial Board membership, and how Sage supports and rewards active EBMs.

Why become an editorial board member: advancing your research and career

Editorial Board membership brings with it a number of opportunities to advance your research, network within your field, and develop your career prospects. You can also advance your academic community's growth by selecting and publishing high-quality research, collaborating with other members of the journal's leadership team by making editorial decisions, managing the peer-review process, and guiding the journal's overall strategy. Here at Sage, we are dedicated to helping you make the most of it.

While the specifics may differ slightly from journal to journal, as an Editorial Board Member you will need to:

  1. Engage in peer review. This is an integral part of the role as reviewing helps to ensure that the articles a journal publishes are academically sound.
  2. Be an editorial content advisor. As an expert in your field, you can advise on the direction of the journal by contributing your experience and insights regarding emerging areas of research (‘hot topics’). With this responsibility comes the opportunity to develop your own research agenda.
  3. Help develop the Editorial Board. Our journals are always keen to work with the latest ‘rising stars’, as well as prominent researchers in a field – your advice on potential new Editorial Board Members is very valuable and is encouraged. Browse and share 'Starting out: early career researchers and editorial board membership' on this page for more information about opportunities for early-career researchers.
  4. Act as an ambassador for the journal. We encourage you to promote the journal where possible – either at conferences or through your own academic or professional networks. Explore our promote your journal and promote your article resources for more advice on how to use your platform to help spread the word about the journal.
Mentorship, networking & collaboration

Being part of an Editorial Board allows you to engage with professionals, scholars, and experts from all over the world. While serving on an Editorial Board, there are often opportunities to meet and work with professionals within your field - whether at board meetings at conferences, in online board meetings, or through collaborative working on a journal project such as a Special Collection or Special Issue. Many journals at Sage also have mentorship or editorial fellowship opportunities that allow early-career researchers to gain valuable experience. Additionally, we at Sage work with our journal editors and society partners to help develop their editorial board members, making involvement with Sage journals rewarding regardless of how advanced your academic career is.

Developing your research agenda: Shaping a Journal’s editorial focus and direction

As part of an Editorial Board, you are integral in shaping the direction of the journal. Your work involves not only ensuring the journal publishes rigorously peer-reviewed research but also advising on areas of emerging or rapidly evolving research that should form part of the journal’s focus, allowing you to shine a spotlight within the academic literature on your particular areas of interest.

  • Editorial Board Members are encouraged to apply to act as Guest Editors for Special Collections and Special Issues on ‘hot topics’ – this is a great way to advance your research and portfolio. Special Collections and Special Issues aim to bring together an international, timely body of research within an important topic area, directing the conversation and bringing focus to new and essential research.
    • As Guest Editor, you’ll refine the topic and specific research areas for the Collection or issue, reach out to your networks to encourage contributions, and editorially shape the final body of work. Published collections can be a brilliant asset in teaching and classroom content. Finally, this often provides opportunities for colleagues at different stages of their careers to collaborate, bringing with it important networking and career opportunities.
    • Discover our Sage Perspectives blog post on ‘Top tips on preparing a successful Special Collection proposal’ for further insight on this process.
  • Editorial Board Members are also encouraged to submit Review articles on ‘hot topics’ in the field, as well as submit their original research, in order to help curate and shape the journal’s development.
Personal and professional development

Serving on an Editorial Board can be an enriching experience that fosters your professional growth. It allows you to stay up to date with the latest research and developments in your field. Reviewing manuscripts can also enhance your own knowledge and expertise. Editorial Board membership will help you develop as an author, reviewer and educator, and allow you to maximise your value and impact within your academic sphere. At Sage, we understand the critical importance of securing grants and funding to advance your research career, and are here to help – this webinar on how to secure funding is a great place to start.

Editorial board members as gatekeepers of the scholarly record

Joining an Editorial Board allows you to be involved in editorial work such as the selection, shaping and curation of high-quality research - you, therefore, play a key role in the advancement and dissemination of knowledge within your field. Through your work on the Editorial Board, you help ensure the quality and integrity of published content, maintain the standards of the publication and contribute to the overall body of knowledge that can impact future studies and policy decisions.

Peer review: Why do it, and how to get involved?

The peer-review process is essential to the development of research across all subject areas, ensuring the integrity of the scientific record, and an important step towards gaining the experience required to join an Editorial Board is to become a strong peer reviewer.

As a reviewer, you help authors improve their papers and further develop their knowledge, and you also benefit from being able to read cutting-edge research prior to publication and before anyone else in the field. Most importantly, as a reviewer, you get the satisfaction of knowing you are contributing directly to the development of your chosen field.

Peer reviewing can be time-consuming. Reviewers need to carefully read and analyse the manuscript, assess the methodology, data analysis, and results, and provide detailed feedback - this process can be demanding, especially when reviewing complex or lengthy manuscripts. We recognize peer-reviewers are often juggling multiple professional and personal responsibilities, and finding the time to review manuscripts alongside other commitments can be challenging.

Reviewer resources and guidance:
Recognition for your peer-review service:
  • Web of Science Researcher Profiles: As part of our commitment to supporting the reviewer community, we are partnered with Web of Science Reviewer Recognition, a service that gets you recognition for your peer review contributions.  We encourage all of our authors and reviewers and members of editorial teams to create a profile.
    • If you need to provide evidence that you have reviewed for a Sage journal, such as for funding, promotions, jobs, or green card applications, you can download your Web of Science CV as a record of your activity. Alternatively, you can share the email sent to you confirming your review has been received.
    • Web of Science Reviewer Recognition is a free service that enables you to effortlessly record, verify, and showcase your peer review contributions. Web of Science Reviewer Recognition records the number of papers you have reviewed for a journal while maintaining reviewer anonymity in accordance with each journal’s review policy. Our partnership with Web of Science Reviewer Recognition enables you to get recognition quickly and easily for your work.
    • For more information, please see the Web of Science Reviewer Recognition page or browse the Reviewer Recognition FAQs for reviewers.
  • ORCID: You can also use ORCID to gain recognition for your reviews.
  • Editorial Review Boards : In order to further improve the recognition and rewards we provide to our reviewers, a number of journals have created Editorial Review Boards. These are sub-sections of the Editorial Board whose primary responsibility is to peer-review for the journal, and they allow journals to better distribute the peer-review workload among the academic community, better engage with researchers earlier on in their career, ensure consistency, quality, and timeliness in peer review, and provide better recognition and reward for peer-review service.
  • Other rewards: Every time you review for a Sage journal, you receive these reviewer rewards:
  • Free access to Sage Journals for 60 days. This will give you access to content from 1999-present for more than 1000 journals across the humanities, social sciences, science, technical and medical fields, including new issues published during the free 60-day period.
  • Register your interest as a reviewer:
  •  Join an Editorial Review Board:
    • Information on the benefits of joining an Editorial Review Board, whether you are eligible to apply, and how you can apply, can be found here.

Starting out: early career researchers and editorial board membership

Whether you are a researcher currently working on an advanced degree, like a PhD or postdoc, or are only a few years out of your program, Sage offers an abundance of resources and services to support early career researchers (ECRs) throughout this initial stage as you work to establish yourself in your chosen field. If you are interested in serving on a Journal’s Editorial Board but are not sure about the steps involved, this page is a great place to start.

When considering Editorial Board Member applications, journals usually look for the following, and Sage supports you through each of these milestones:

  • Researchers that are well-published and impactful in their field of research
  • Researchers with strong peer-review capability
  • Researchers that explore Guest Editor opportunities

Researchers that are active and engaged in their community (e.g., experience presenting at academic conferences or involvement in professional organizations)

Career path illustrated as a timeline with 9 milestones

Becoming a well-published author in your area of research is usually a pre-requisite for joining an editorial board. Sage has an abundance of information to support you as an author, see Information for authors. Here we signpost some specific resources that will help you as you embark on your journey as an author.

An important step towards gaining the experience required to join an Editorial Board is to become a strong peer reviewer. Advice and guidance on why you should peer-review for Sage and how you can get involved can be found on this page.

A growing number of journals at Sage are launching Editorial Review Boards, which are sub-sections of the Editorial Board specifically aimed at researchers earlier on in their careers. Joining an Editorial Review Board provides researchers with vital peer-review experience, valuable experience working closely alongside journal Editors and Editorial Boards, as well as recognition and reward for peer review. Editorial Review Board members may also be considered for advancement to the full Editorial Board when these positions become available. More information on the benefits of joining an Editorial Review Board, whether you are eligible to apply, and how you can apply, can be found here.

As the Society for Scholarly Publishing (SSP) states, “Mentorship is an ideal way for professionals at all career levels to develop new relationships, share experiences, and learn from others outside their organizations by connecting with a mentor.” As most researchers who sit on an Editorial Board tend to be further along in their career, many Sage journals offer a variety of mentoring or editorial fellowship opportunities for early-career researchers, as well as junior editorial positions such as Social Media Editor or Editorial Review Board Member, to help ECRs establish themselves. Explore a valuable blog post on the topic of ‘Joining an Early Career Researcher Editorial Board: My Experience’ for a first-hand account of joining an editorial board as an early career researcher.

If you are looking to gain a better understanding of what is going on from within or outside of your academic community and are hoping to strengthen your professional network, Sage can help.

EBMs with teaching and mentoring responsibilities

If you have reached the stage in your career where teaching, lecturing and mentoring form part of your role, Sage has a suite of resources to support you here too.

Sage has Community Sites that allow you to engage with Sage community members, through a platform in which researchers and educators within different fields can share ideas related to academic work, teaching, and the latest research and best practices.

Why Sage - rewards for active Sage editorial board members

We understand that as an engaged member of the research community, you have a multitude of commitments competing for your attention alongside your day-to-day work – whether it’s applying for grants, securing funding, writing and peer-reviewing academic papers, teaching, presenting at or attending conferences – the list is endless.

In recognition of this, Sage is committed to supporting your career goals, providing you with opportunities and resources to help you develop as a researcher and progress within your field, and properly recognize the vital contribution you provide when you serve on an Editorial Board. We also ensure that opportunities for progression from peer reviewer to Editorial Board Member all the way through to Editor are available to our community.

As our way of directly thanking our community, we make available to all active Editorial Board Members a carefully curated portfolio of helpful classroom, research and teaching resources designed to support teaching effectiveness and research endeavours.

These include:

  • Teaching/lecturing advice/aids, Sage Video, blogs, wikis, podcasts, and web tools for classrooms
  • Sage Books & Reference on teaching in Higher Education
  • Content on how to secure research grants/funding
  • Sage Books & Reference on writing grant proposals
  • Content on how to advance your academic career/professional development
  • Books and References on mentoring and working with Doctoral Researchers
  • Resources for assessing the communication of Science
  • Dependent upon the journal, editorial board members may receive gratis access to the journal as a benefit of serving on the journal's editorial board. Please reach out to the journal editor or your Sage contact for further assistance.

We also provide:

  • A promotion, tenure or re-contracting toolkit: Acting as an Editorial Board Member provides experience that can lend itself to promotion and tenure packets, but we recognise that there is often little guidance provided for these applications. To help with this, we offer a toolkit to help mentor you on how to put together (as well as incorporate your editorial service into) your tenure/re-contracting/promotional packets.
  • Templates for our Editors to use for recommendation letters, so that they can sing your praises as Editorial Board Member to provide additional weight to your tenure/re-contracting/promotion applications.
By joining a Sage Editorial Board, you will also play a fundamental role in upholding and contributing to our DEI pledges, which include amplifying diverse voices and increasing representation. We at Sage are proud to publish high-quality, peer-reviewed interdisciplinary content from authors and editors of all backgrounds. We have clear commitments to showcasing a diverse range of content, as well as representations of people and populations, and are committed to platform inclusivity and accessibility. Therefore, through your work as an Editorial Board Member, you will be contributing to our mission to build bridges to knowledge, which means enabling people from all backgrounds to contribute to scholarship and working to ensure our publishing processes are unencumbered by bias and prejudice.
Testimonials

You may be interested in