Confronting Poverty: Measuring Its Causes, Costs, and Consequences

Read Time - 8 minutes

This volume explores the evolution of poverty measurement and social programs over the past two decades, highlighting the shift from the outdated Official Poverty Measure to the more comprehensive Supplemental Poverty Measure.

Research


The views expressed are those of the authors and do not reflect the views of the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago or the Federal Reserve System.  

Over the past two decades there have been dramatic shifts in how we measure poverty, and how we address it through social programs. This ANNALS volume, which was organized as a posthumous tribute to Rebecca “Becky” Blank, examines these changes and their implications along with a range of related topics. 

In 2023, the United States Federal government spent $545 billion on programs to combat poverty, but the Official Poverty Measure (OPM) in place since the 1960s fails to account for many of these resources. As a result, the OPM has shown little sustained reduction in poverty over time—consistent with President Ronald Reagan’s old quip that the “federal government fought the war on poverty, and poverty won.” The innovative Supplemental Poverty Measure (SPM) better accounts for the totality of resources families have available to spend and the demands on those resources, and uses an improved, empirically based poverty threshold level. The result is that the SPM changes both the number and composition of who is considered poor. As shown in the figure below, SPM poverty started off higher in the late 1960s and fell sharply prior to 1979. Over the next several decades, the SPM has been higher than the OPM but has moved largely—though not perfectly—in parallel to it, with much of the fluctuation in both measures  driven by economic booms and busts. The measures diverge starkly in 2020–2021, because the SPM reflects the historic relief payments made during that time while the OPM does not incorporate many of them. In recent decades, the design of the safety net also has shifted to providing increased incentives and rewards for work.

Figure: Percentage of People in Poverty Over Time, Official Poverty Measure versus Supplemental Poverty Measure 
Notes: Poverty rate data from Wimer et al. (2022) and Shrider and Creamer (2023), recession dates from National Bureau of Economic Research (2023).

Against this backdrop, the volume covers a range of topics exploring poverty policy, poverty measurement, and their interactions. Papers document the changing characteristics of people living in poverty, including differences across age and geography, and by race and ethnicity, and the changing likelihood of employment among those in poverty. Several papers investigate recent changes in safety net programs, studying differences in policies’ impacts across groups such as children and older adults, a deep dive into the safety net’s response to economic expansions and recessions, how the safety net responds when people newly fall into poverty, and recent declines in participation in the safety net among immigrant families.

Health care and health insurance is an important component of financial well-being. Addressing this, one paper explores opportunities to further refine poverty measurement to better measure medical expenses and insurance needs. Another paper explores how the Affordable Care Act has reduced the gap in health insurance coverage between full- and part-time workers

The volume concludes with papers on a range topics that were important aspects of Becky’s career. One paper draws lessons from the University of Wisconsin’s Bucky’s Tuition Promise which made college financial aid access simpler and more transparent. Another paper tracks a fascinating – and at times a jaw-dropping – history of women’s progress over the past 50 years across education, economics, government, public policy, medicine, and business. Recent Moynihan prize winner Alan Blinder gives advice on how to bridge the gap between “politicos” and academics to improve real-world policy decision-making. The final paper reflects on the integration of religious convictions with academic and policy work connecting it to Becky’s “economic theology”.

The volume is a tribute to Becky’s remarkable contributions in academia, government, and scholarship.

Read the full volume

Issue Details

Confronting Poverty: Measuring Its Causes, Costs, and Consequences
Guest Editor: Leslie McGranahan, Diane W. Schanzenbach
First Published: January 2024

The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science

Share this article

The latest from Sage Perspectives

The work AI is taking is the work that makes experts

August 05, 2026 Read Time - 9 minutes